If a drill bit is flexing, walking off the mark, or producing a hole that is not where you started, choose a screw-machine-length bit when the required hole is shallow enough. Also called a stub-length drill, it has shorter flutes and a shorter overall length than a same-diameter jobber bit. That shorter unsupported length makes it more rigid, helping reduce deflection and wandering in metal.

Use a jobber-length bit when you need its reach. A jobber drill is the everyday general-purpose length because its longer flutes can drill deeper holes, but that extra length also makes it easier for a small-diameter bit to flex. Bit length is only one part of the choice: select the material, point geometry, coating, and diameter separately for the metal and hole you need.

The practical difference

Screw-machine-length and jobber-length bits are both twist drills. The key difference is their proportions, not the basic cutting action.

  • Screw-machine-length drill: Shorter overall length and flute length. It is commonly called a stub drill or stubby drill.
  • Jobber-length drill: Longer overall length and flute length. It is the common all-purpose style found in many drill-bit indexes.

For a given diameter, the shorter drill has less length available to bend. That added rigidity can improve hole location and reduce runout-related problems, particularly when drilling metal. Suppliers and cutting-tool manufacturers describe stub drills as a choice for compact setups and reduced deflection, while jobber drills prioritize general-purpose reach. Drill Bit Warehouse and Regal Cutting Tools both identify that reach-versus-rigidity tradeoff.

Choose a screw-machine-length bit when rigidity matters more than reach

A short drill is usually the better choice when all of these are true:

  • The required hole depth is well within the bit’s flute length.
  • You are drilling metal and want to limit flex at the cutting point.
  • The hole must start close to a marked location.
  • The drill setup has limited clearance above the workpiece.
  • You are using a drill press, mill, lathe, screw machine, or a well-controlled handheld drill setup.
  • The diameter is small enough that a long bit would be noticeably whippy.

The shorter design can be particularly helpful for shallow clearance holes, pilot holes, spot-weld removal, fixture work, and holes near an edge where a wandering bit would cause trouble. Screw-machine drills are also useful where a long bit would run into a machine head, body panel, bracket, or nearby obstruction before the hole is complete.

A stub drill does not automatically make every hole precise. A loose drill chuck, spindle runout, poor workholding, a dull point, an uneven surface, or side pressure can still make the bit walk or cut oversize. But removing unnecessary bit length is a simple way to reduce one major source of deflection.

Choose a jobber-length bit when you need reach

A jobber-length drill is the better default when you need a hole deeper than a stub bit can reasonably drill or when the drilling point sits below a surface that the short bit cannot reach.

Use a jobber bit for:

  • Through-holes in material too thick for the stub drill’s flute length.
  • Holes in deep channels, recessed brackets, or boxed sections.
  • General shop work where one versatile set must cover many ordinary tasks.
  • Situations where the drill body needs to clear the workpiece while the point reaches the hole location.

Jobber drills are widely used because they offer a useful middle ground between short stub drills and specialty long-series drills. Their longer flutes allow more drilling depth, but the bit should not be selected simply because it is the longest one that fits the chuck. Regal Cutting Tools notes that jobber drills commonly have flute lengths roughly 9 to 14 times their diameter, whereas stub drills are intended for shorter-reach work.

A shorter bit is not always the right answer

Do not use a stub drill simply because it is stronger. It has real limitations.

Limited drilling depth

The fluted section carries chips away from the cutting point. A screw-machine bit can drill only shallow holes relative to a jobber bit of the same diameter. If the hole approaches the end of the flutes, chip evacuation becomes more difficult and the bit can bind, overheat, or leave a poor-quality hole.

Check the listed flute length, not just the overall length. Product charts show that both dimensions vary by diameter and manufacturer. For example, screw-machine drill charts list separate overall and flute lengths for each size. DrillsandCutters.com

Less access to recessed locations

A short bit may fit under a low obstruction, but it cannot reach a hole located far inside a recess. “Tight space” can mean either limited vertical clearance or limited access depth. A stub drill helps with the first problem; a longer drill may be necessary for the second.

No substitute for a proper starting surface

A stub drill reduces the tendency to bend, but it cannot reliably start on a rounded, sloped, badly marked, or uneven surface by itself. For accurate metal holes, make a positive starting mark when appropriate, keep the drill aligned with the work, and begin with controlled pressure.

Drill length does not determine bit grade or point style

“Screw-machine” and “jobber” describe length series. They do not tell you whether the bit is HSS, cobalt, carbide, black oxide, uncoated, split-point, or a particular drill-point angle.

Choose those features separately:

  • Material grade: Match the bit material to the workpiece and the demands of the operation. A short HSS bit and a short cobalt bit can both be screw-machine length, but they are not equivalent for every metal.
  • Point geometry: A split point can help reduce skating at startup. Other point geometries may suit particular materials or production operations.
  • Coating or finish: A finish can affect corrosion resistance, lubricity, or wear behavior, but it does not turn an unsuitable bit into the right one.
  • Diameter and tolerance: Choose the size required by the fastener, tap, reamer allowance, or clearance-hole specification.

For more on selecting drill-bit material independently from bit length, see HSS vs. cobalt vs. carbide drill bits.

How to decide in under a minute

Ask these questions in order:

  1. How deep is the hole? If a screw-machine bit has sufficient flute length with room for chip clearing, it is a candidate. If not, use a jobber or another longer series.
  2. How important is hole location? For a shallow hole where wandering would be costly, favor the short bit.
  3. Is the bit small relative to its length? The smaller the diameter and the longer the bit, the more rigidity becomes valuable.
  4. What kind of access problem do you have? Choose a stub drill for limited headroom; choose a longer drill for a deeply recessed target.
  5. What metal are you drilling? Then choose the appropriate drill material, point, cutting fluid approach, and drilling technique independently of length.

Setup matters as much as drill length

A short bit is most effective in a stable setup. Secure the workpiece so it cannot spin or shift, hold the drill square to the surface, and avoid forcing the bit sideways. Clear chips as needed rather than trying to drive a bit continuously beyond what the flutes can carry.

For handheld drilling, use the drill’s current manual for instructions on chucking the bit, holding the tool, workpiece support, and any accessory limitations. For drill presses and machine tools, verify the machine manual’s workholding and operating guidance before drilling metal. A bit that catches in metal can pull the workpiece or twist the tool unexpectedly.

If a bit has begun wandering, also inspect the point for damage and check whether the chuck is holding it concentrically. How to check drill runout can help separate a bit-length issue from a drill or chuck issue.

Bottom line

Choose a screw-machine-length drill bit when you need a shallow metal hole and want the greatest practical rigidity from a conventional twist drill. Its short body is less prone to flex, so it is often better for accurate starts, small holes, and compact machine or handheld setups.

Choose a jobber-length bit when the hole depth or recessed location demands more reach. It remains the more versatile general-purpose length, but use only as much length as the job requires. The best bit is not necessarily the shortest or longest one—it is the shortest suitable bit with the right diameter, material, and point geometry for the hole.

References

  1. How To Choose the Right Drill Bit Length. (n.d.). https://www.drillbitwarehouse.com/how-to-choose-the-right-drill-bit-length
  2. Screw Machine Drill Bit Chart | Stub Drill Lengths | DrillsandCutters.com. (n.d.). https://drillsandcutters.com/screw-machine-stub-drill-bit-chart
  3. Twist Drill Length: Which is Right for You - And Why it Matters | Regal Cutting Tools. (n.d.). https://regalcuttingtools.com/twist-drill-length-which-is-right-for-you-and-why-it-matters
  4. Jobber Length Drill Bits | AFT Fasteners. (n.d.). https://www.aftfasteners.com/jobber-length-2
  5. Drill bit lengths | The Hobby-Machinist. (n.d.). https://www.hobby-machinist.com/threads/drill-bit-lengths.29172
  6. 3/8 in. Wire Size Screw Machine Length Drill Bit. (n.d.). https://www.bigrocksupply.com/3/8-in-wire-size-screw-machine-length-drill-bit.aspx
  7. 3/8 in. Wire Size Screw Machine Length Drill Bit. (n.d.). https://bigrocksupply.com/3/8-in-wire-size-screw-machine-length-drill-bit.aspx
  8. Precision Jobber Length Drill Bits | Baucor. (n.d.). https://www.baucor.com/collections/jobber-length-drill-bits
  9. Tips on Drill Bit Selection - THE BLUE PRINT. (n.d.). https://blueprint.fastenal.com/drill-bit-selection.html
  10. Any downside to using jobber length drill bits - The Garage Journal. (n.d.). https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/threads/any-downside-to-using-jobber-length-drill-bits.430958